Jersey Mikes Sub in a Tub

in Fast Food Guides

Jersey Mike’s Sub in a Tub Guide for Low Carb Dieters

Learn how to order a Jersey Mike’s sub in a tub like an expert.

See real-life photos of my actual low carb Jersey Mike’s sub in a tub orders.

Get my printable Jersey Mike’s sub in a tub low carb menu to see macros for their different low carb burger options.

What To Order

Jersey Mike’s is best known as a sandwich restaurant that offers both cold sandwiches and hot sandwiches. For some of the sandwiches, they fresh slice the deli meats right in front of you.

While we can’t eat the bread, they do serve “subs in a tub” which are low carb friendly.

Below are the sub in a tubs I’ve tried so far along with their macros. I arranged them in order of my preference.

1. Chicken Philly Cheese Steak Sub in a Tub

Comes with chicken, peppers, onions, and melted white American cheese that’s grilled-to-order on their flat top grill in-store and then served on a bed of lettuce. I had them add their olive oil blend, red wine vinegar and spices to give it some additional flavor.

This was my favorite meal at Jersey Mike’s.

Low Carb Jersey Mikes Sub In a Tub - No 16 Chicken Philly Cheese Steak

My Chicken Philly Cheese Steak Sub in a Tub

  • How To Order: “#16 Chicken Philly — sub in a tub style. Add oil, vinegar, & spices.”
  • Estimated Macros: 655 calories, 13g net carbs, 49g fat, and 37g protein.
  • Price: $7.45

If you’re wondering where all the carbs come from on this meal, my menu research suggests the chicken has about 5g net carbs, the grilled peppers have another 5g net carbs, the cheese has 1-2g net carbs, and the lettuce has 1-2g net carbs.

2. Jersey Mike’s Famous Philly Sub in a Tub

Comes with steak, peppers, onions, and melted white American cheese that’s grilled-to-order on their flat top grill in-store and then served on a bed of lettuce. I had them add their olive oil blend, red wine vinegar and spices to give it some additional flavor.

This one is almost as good as the Chicken Philly.

Low Carb Jersey Mikes Sub in a Tub No 17 Famous Philly

My Famous Philly Sub in a Tub

  • How To Order: #17 Famous Philly — sub in a tub style. Add oil, vinegar, & spices.
  • Estimated Macros: 695 calories, 11g net carbs, 55g fat, and 35g protein.
  • Price: $7.45

3. Famous Roast Beef and Provolone Sub in a Tub

Comes with fresh-sliced roast beef and provolone on top of a bed of lettuce. I had it served “Mike’s Way” which means the sandwich artists adds sliced tomatoes & onions, spices, olive oil and vinegar. I also asked for mayo and sliced banana peppers on top.

Low Carb Jersey Mikes Sub in a Tub - No 6 Roast Beef and Provolone

My Roast Beef and Provolone Sub in a Tub

  • How To Order: #6 Famous Roast Beef and Provolone sub in a tub — Mike’s Way.
  • Estimated Macros: 690 calories, 9g net carbs, 50g fat, and 47g protein.
  • Price: $7.85

If I had to do this order over again, I might cut the tomatoes as they had 2g net carbs and make the meal a little inconvenient to eat with a fork.

4. BLT Sub in a Tub

Perfect option if you’re doing dairy free or are looking for something with a high fat-to-carb ratio. The BLT comes with bacon, shredded lettuce, and sliced tomatoes. I had it served with mayo, oil, vinegar, and seasoning for added flavor.

Low Carb Jersey Mikes Sub in a Tub No 1 BLT

My BLT Sub in a Tub

  • How To Order: #1 BLT sub in a tub. Add mayo, oil, vinegar, and spices.
  • Estimated Macros: 1005 calories, 6g net carbs, 102g fat, and 12g protein.
  • Price: $6.85

5. “Cancro Special” Sub in a Tub

Cancro, in case you’re wondering, refers to the last name of Jersey Mike’s CEO, Peter Cancro. This sub in a tub is perfect for meat lovers. Comes with sliced roast beef, pepperoni, and provolone. I had it served “Mike’s Way” with onions, tomatoes, spices, oil & vinegar.

Low Carb Jersey Mikes Subs #12 Cancro Special

My #12 “Cancro Special” Sub in a Tub

  • How To Order: #12 Cancro Special served as a sub in a tub — Mike’s Way.
  • Estimated Macros: 740 calories, 9g net carbs, 54g fat, and 50g protein.
  • Price: $7.85

What To Avoid

Just in case you’re new to low carb eating, you can’t have any of the breads, tortilla wraps, or chips at Jersey Mike’s.

Some locations have soups which must be avoided because they’re too high carb.

They also have some hot subs which sound relatively low carb but aren’t. Here’s the list to avoid:

Avoid these Hot Subs In a Tub

  • #19 BBQ Beef – 38 net carbs
  • #44 Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak – 18 net carbs
  • Teriyaki Chicken Cheesesteak – 23 net carbs
  • #42 Chipotle Chicken – 16 net carbs
  • #55 Chicken Big Kahuna – 16 net carbs
  • Buffalo Steak Cheesesteak – 16 net carbs

Avoid these Condiments & Dressings

  • Thousand Island – 8 net carbs
  • Honey Mustard – 7 net carbs

Overall Ratings

I rate Jersey Mike’s as low carb friendly because they offer the sub in a tub.

  • Low carb friendly – Yes.
  • Low carb entrees on menu –  Not Really. Must special  request a sub in a tub.
  • Satiety of low carb entrees – Above average. Surprisingly, I didn’t need to order extra meat or cheese to feel satisfied.
  • Taste of low carb entrees – Average. Their hot cheese steak subs were better than their cold bus.
  • Price / value of low carb entrees –  Average. About $7-$8 per sub in a tub.
  • Ordering experience – Average. They were friendly both times I visited, but made mistakes on my orders and weren’t good at answering menu questions.

Here are links to my reviews of Jimmy John’s and Subway if you want other low carb sandwich options.

What’s Next

My next low carb fast food guide should be out soon. Subscribe here to get it:

Follow My Low Carb Fast Food Challenge

Get my specific recommendations on what to order every time you're in a Top 30 fast food chain like McDonald's, Subway, or Chick Fil A, etc.

I won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by ConvertKit

And you’ll get some simple low carb recipes and other tips from me for all the times you’re not eating in a fast food joint.

Cheers,
Ryan
aka “Mr. SkinnyPants”

Share this post to help change lives

Leave a Reply

  1. Thank you for doing Jersey Mikes, a frequent stop for me. I’ve been doing the #8 (club) and the #13 (Italian), both n the tub. I don’t know the macros but felt I was doing ok. Just curious on what size your ordered? Jersey Mikes offer a mini, regular and giant. I assume you ordered the regular but thought I should ask because the macros could be way different if you based your macros on the mini. Thank you again.